Monday, July 16, 2007

July 9, 2007

The regular Board Meeting began with introductions of Dr. Jim Leary, the new Interim Superintendent and the 2 new student representatives. I missed the names of the student reps and, of course, they were not listed on the agenda so I will try to get that information at a later date. Also introduced in the audience was Bob Haley, the new principal at Lakeshore School. Pres. O'Brien also took a few minutes to thank Bill Klaus for his years of service as the Superintendent and wish him luck in his service as the new principal of Northstar.

DIGRESSION: Mr. O'Brien also noted that they forgot to recognize Dr. Gregg Butler's retirement and giving him a plaque at GB's last meeting. Maybe they didn't bother to say "good-bye" and "thank you" since they didn't think he was really leaving (?!?!) A community member reported to me that she heard from an administrator's wife that GB never even cleaned out his office after he retired! Word on the street is that he basically continued business as usual at work waiting for the official "annointing" when he would just move his office next door when Klaus left. Then when he did not get the Interim Sup. job, he cleaned out his office and left in the middle of the night! My husband's comment: "Just like the Baltimore Colts!"

Comm. Cummins noted that a local healthcare provider had done a community survey about issues that are of most concern and coming in 2nd place, just behind the local economy, was concern about public education. So, we are most definitely not out of the woods with the community.

Int. Sup Leary offered to conduct a session for BOE members about board functioning. Date is set for Aug. 6th at 4:30 p.m.

The Public Comment session was led off by Dr. Maureen Mack (sp?) who was commenting on the upcoming search process for a new superintendent. She encouraged the BOE to look to the future and to cast a very wide net for candidates. She also indicated that the search committee should include all of the school district partners from the community and internally (teachers and other staff.) The candidate pool should be sufficiently large and diverse and if we do not have the candidates who meet our requirements to seek help and restart the search if necessary.

I used my few minutes of comments to AGAIN seek to build ways to allow for MEANINGFUL COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION relying on the examples presented by the ECCF. When starting up the ECCF they sought to gain participation by 24 families and got 62! With the Women's Circle their goal was 50 women and they got 162. "If you build it they will come." Pretty simple but it doesn't seem to be catching on with BOE members. I also encouraged the BOE to involve community members in the Superintendent search from the beginning of the process. Thirdly, I commented that Pres. O'Brien's comments about a Conflict of Interest Policy having a "chilling effect" was not reasonable because if there are more ways to get involved there can be more participation for many people. I also indicated that many community members who would not publicly state their concerns about Board conflicts have done so to me and will simply vote their opposition at referendum time. Finally, I commented that the discussion about Little Red seems to have not gone anywhere in 3 months and that this discussion cannot take place in isolation without the entire planning process or the result would be just one more short term, incremental decision that leaves the public distrustful.

JJ Henricks commented that it is a big loss to the students of the district that many AP classes were cut, especially the loss of AP History. This is the kind of thing that she and her husband and many others investigate before deciding about a community.

A staff member from WASB gave a presentation and suggested timeline for the search for the new superintendent and WASB's availability of resources to help in that search. The fee would be under $10,000. She said that posting the job on the internet gets it broadcast very widely but that current board members and community members are key resources to identify potential candidates as well.

Mr. Jim Kling gave a sobering presentation on the extensive staff cuts at each school and grade level. Unfortunately, there were not adequate copies of his material for the audience nor were they put out ahead of time to be included in the Public Comment portion of the Agenda. Hey, folks, come on back on July 23rd and comment at that point!!

Board members discussed the seriousness of the cuts and resulting increases in class sizes. It was noted that due to the extremely short time frame between the failure of the referendum and the teacher contract deadlines, there was little time to plan or even discuss how cuts would be made based on programming priorities. Sad, sad, sad. More than a year ago the BOE faced a budget deficit of $7 million and just decided to take the whole thing out of the fund balance. Even that alarming move did not motivate the leadership to plan at all. So the next year they have 3 weeks to solve a $9 million problem.

Under "Other Business" Pres. O'Brien attempted to clarify some legal details about the Wisconsin State Supreme Court ruling against the Tomah School District to have more informative agendas to communicate to the community. He spent several minutes shuffling papers and mumbling incomprehensible fragments of sentences that were unintelligible to all present. At the end, no one knew what the point he was trying to make was, other than "don't hire this guy as your attorney" when you are relying on clarity in front of a judge.

There was also a comment about the state budget from the Assembly being $85 less than Doyle's. Brent Wogahn repeated several times that "equalization aid" just means "property tax relief" and doesn't give any more $'s to education. Again, not very informative to us average bears in the audience.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I seem to detect a note of concern in your reports about specific board members and some indication that you might like to see some change.

As I understand it there are four ways to change a school board:

1. recall elections
2, regular elections
3, district court orders
4, replacing a vacancy on the Board

This post concerns only the second option as I have no interest in the others, although I have researched them to some degree.


Some local political observations

The following is a look at some past school board elections and a preview of upcoming local elections for city Council and County Board.

Recent history of school board elections 2004 - present

School Board members serve three year terms on a two members, two members , three members three year cycle of election .

April 2004 (three members elected- five candidates )

Incumbent M. Olsen did not run

Incumbents Evans, and
C. Olson reelected
New member Woghan elected

candidates not elected:
Schwartz
Johnson



April 2005 (two memberts elected- four candidates )

Incumbent O'Brien reelected
New member Craig elected

Incumbent Joyal not reelcted
candidate not elected:
Tappen



April 2006- (two members elected -three candidates )

Trish Cummings new member added
Mary Kneer incumbent reelected.

Bob Janke incumbent not reelected


April 2007- (three members elected- seven candidates )

Olson and Evans incumbents did
not run.

Wogahn % incumbent reelected.
New members Bollinger%,
Faanes % * elected.

Other candidates not elected:
Schwartz # (eliminated in
primary)
Henley * #
Stanley #
Janke *

* endoresed by ECAE (Eau Claire Area Educators)
# endorsed by Progressive Majority of Wiscsonsin
% ran joint advertizing campaign

endorsements included only for this most recent election
note- incumbents seem to do well

Future elections

April 2008- (two members to be elected)

Michael O'Brien term expires
Carol Craig term expires

April 2009- (two members to be elected)

Mary Kneer term expires
Trish Cummins term expires

April 2010 (three members to be elected)

Michael Bollinger term expires
Ken Fannes term expires
Brent Woghan term expires

Recent School Board Referenda

1998 $39 million referendum for building repair and replacement and
technology additions. defeated
1999 $50 million facilites referendum passed
2007 $21 million referendum for operating expenses for three years defeated

Future referendum (not determined)


___________________________



Expiration dates for terms of City Council, and County Board members.



April 2008

At large City Council members (five to be elected)
Hal Davis
Kerri Kincaid
Thomas Vue
Raymond Hughes
Brandon Buchanan

all 29 Eau Claire County Board Supervisors


April 2010

City Council members and Council president
David Adler, Council President
District Council members
Thomas Kemp
David Klinghammer
Beryle S. Middleton
Bob Von Haden
David L. Duax
all 29 County Board Supervisors.

Nomination papers for local elections are available the first week in December with filing deadlines early in January. If a primary election is needed it is held in February.



A major factor in local elections is the turnout of voters. Usually the turnout is very low in the 20% or below range with wide variation from ward to ward with the student wards being very low.

- caveat there may be some minor discrepancies in my history of prevsious school board elections- for example, I seem to have lost a member, Gary McFarland, in terms of when he came on and left the board. But I do have the data to support recent events and elections, including ward by ward voting results.